I had a patient—a young woman from Lyon—who came to me with persistent dermatitis around her eyes and mouth. She had switched to what she called 'natural' products from a luxury brand, all beautifully packaged, heavily fragranced. She believed 'natural' meant gentle. Quelle horreur! I smiled and told her, 'In dermatology, the nose is not the best judge of safety.'
Fragrance, even from essential oils, is one of the most common causes of allergic contact dermatitis in France and worldwide. Her skin was reacting not to the ingredients that treated, but to the ones that scented. I recommended a switch to fragrance-free products—no lavender, no rose, no citrus. Just clean, simple formulations. Three weeks later, her skin had calmed completely. She looked at me and said, ‘I didn’t know silence could feel so good.’ I replied, ‘Sometimes, the best skincare is the one you don’t smell, et Voila.’
While fragrance can make skincare feel luxurious, it's can be a detrimental ingredient, especially in concentrated products.
Here's a breakdown of the reasons to opt for unscented serums:
1. Reduced Risk of Skin Irritation and Allergic Reactions (The Biggest Reason IMHO)
- Fragrance is a Top Allergen: Fragrance, both natural and synthetic, is a leading cause of contact dermatitis (skin irritation and allergic reactions). This is consistently shown in dermatological research. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) identifies fragrance as a common allergen.
- Sensitization Over Time: Even if you don't react immediately, repeated exposure to fragrance can lead to sensitization. This means your skin becomes increasingly reactive over time, eventually developing an allergy or irritation that wasn't there before. This is a cumulative effect.
- Hidden Ingredients: "Fragrance" on an ingredient list can be a catch-all term for a cocktail of dozens of individual chemicals, many of which are not disclosed. The International Fragrance Association (IFRA) lists thousands of chemicals used in fragrances, and manufacturers are not required to list them individually on product labels. This lack of transparency makes it difficult to pinpoint the specific irritant.
- Synthetic vs. Natural Doesn't Matter: Both synthetic and natural fragrances (like essential oils) can be irritating. "Natural" doesn't automatically equal "safe" for the skin. Many essential oils contain potent compounds (like limonene, linalool, eugenol) that are known skin irritants.
- Serums are Concentrated: Serums are designed to deliver high concentrations of active ingredients. This also means a higher concentration of any fragrance ingredients, increasing the risk of a reaction compared to a product like a cleanser that is quickly washed off.
- Skin Barrier Disruption: Fragrance can disrupt the skin's natural barrier function. A compromised barrier makes the skin more vulnerable to further irritation, dryness, and even infection. It can also exacerbate existing skin conditions.
2. Unscented can be better for sensitive skin (and Many Skin Conditions)
- Eczema, Rosacea, and Psoriasis: Individuals with these conditions have highly reactive skin. Fragrance is a very common trigger for flare-ups. Unscented products are almost always recommended by dermatologists for these conditions.
- Acne-Prone Skin: While not always the primary cause, fragrance can irritate already inflamed skin and potentially worsen acne breakouts. The irritation can lead to more inflammation and clogged pores.
- Post-Procedure Care: After treatments like chemical peels, laser resurfacing, or microdermabrasion, the skin is extremely sensitive. Unscented products are essential to avoid irritation and promote healing.
3. et Biensur! Avoid Potential Endocrine Disruptors
- Phthalates: Some fragrance ingredients, particularly phthalates, are suspected endocrine disruptors. This means they can interfere with the body's hormonal system. While the research is ongoing, and the exact level of risk from skincare is debated, many people choose to avoid phthalates as a precaution. Because fragrance ingredients are often not fully disclosed, it's difficult to know if a scented product contains phthalates, Bonjout le Balm is Phthalates free.
- Precautionary Principle: Given the potential (though not definitively proven) risks, many prefer to err on the side of caution, especially for products applied to the skin and potentially absorbed.
4. Layer Products Without Conflict
- Fragrance Overload: If you use multiple scented products (serum, moisturizer, sunscreen, makeup), the combination of fragrances can be overwhelming and increase the likelihood of irritation. Using unscented products allows you to layer without this concern.
- Ingredient Interactions: While less common, it's theoretically possible for fragrance ingredients to interact negatively with other active ingredients in your skincare routine. Unscented products minimize this risk.
5. Focus on the Active Ingredients
- Marketing vs. Efficacy: Fragrance is often added for marketing purposes – to make a product smell appealing. It doesn't contribute to the serum's actual skincare benefits. Choosing unscented products allows you to focus on the ingredients that actually improve your skin.
- Clearer Ingredient Lists: Unscented products often have simpler, more transparent ingredient lists, making it easier to understand what you're putting on your skin.
What to Look For (and Avoid)
-
"Unscented" vs. "Fragrance-Free":
- Fragrance-Free: This is the ideal term. It means no fragrance ingredients have been added.
- Unscented: This term can be tricky. It can mean that masking fragrances have been added to cover up the natural scent of the ingredients. While this might seem counterintuitive, some ingredients have unpleasant natural odors. Look closely at the ingredient list.
-
Ingredient List Scrutiny: Even if a product claims to be "fragrance-free" or "unscented," always check the ingredient list. Look out for:
- Fragrance/Parfum: The obvious culprits.
- Essential Oils: (e.g., lavender oil, rose oil, citrus oils, tea tree oil, peppermint oil, etc.) While natural, many are potent irritants.
- Fragrant Plant Extracts: (e.g., rose extract, citrus extract)
- Individual Fragrance Components: (e.g., limonene, linalool, geraniol, citronellol, eugenol, coumarin) These are often listed separately, even if "fragrance" isn't.
- Look for certification: Some products will be certified by organizations for sensitive skin.
Choosing unscented skincare serums is a proactive step towards minimizing skin irritation, allergic reactions, and potential long-term health concerns. It's a particularly important consideration for those with sensitive skin, existing skin conditions, or those who prefer a more minimalist and ingredient-focused approach to skincare. While the allure of a beautifully scented product is understandable, the potential downsides of fragrance in a concentrated serum can outweigh the sensory benefits for those with sensitive skin. Prioritizing skin health over fragrance is a sound strategy for long-term skin well-being. À bientôt!